The Blue Crab Opens in St. Michaels Under New Ownership

A historic Odd Fellows lodge, located on Fremont Street in St. Michaels, is home to the Blue Crab, a coffee shop now owned by the Bāgery. In addition to coffee, the Blue Crab offers a breakfast and lunch menu featuring organic bread products made from-scratch in Easton at the Bāgery. The locally-crafted organic products include bagels, english muffins, pastries, sandwich breads, quiche shells, and more.

Bāgery-lovers can expect to see some of the same menu items at the Blue Crab, with new offerings such as breakfast burritos, crab/asparagus/feta quiche, crab cakes, and shrimp salad.

Open 7:00am-3:00pm every day, the Blue Crab is committed to serving quality food and coffee within the historic building. The walls are decorated by the St. Michaels Art League, showing paintings and pictures created by local artists. Most of the art is available for sale. The former lodge, titled “Freedom’s Friend Lodge No. 1024”, was granted permission to open on September 11, 1865, almost four months after the end of the Civil War. The lodge’s title was likely inspired “by the great hope and faith that the end of slavery evoked from the founders of the lodge, many of which were Civil War veterans for the Union Army.” (Archives of Maryland)

Freedom’s Friend Lodge No. 1024 is the oldest-standing Odd Fellows lodge in Maryland, as well as one of the oldest in the country. (Archives of Maryland)
Location: 102 S Fremont Street, St Michaels MD 21663
Hours: 7:00am-3:00pm every day
Website: thebluecrab.com
Contact: management@bluecrabhospitality.com

 

 

AI Disclosure: The Spy and its writers may use artificial intelligence tools to support accuracy and clarity in our reporting.

Write a Letter to the Editor on this Article

We encourage readers to offer their point of view on this article by submitting the following form. Editing is sometimes necessary and is done at the discretion of the editorial staff. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe to the Spy
Receive daily intelligence reports right to your inbox

Dr. Walley New Provider (300x500)
Ad 4 Talbot Spy Rotating Ad 300x500px Chuck Mangold Jr
Talbot Spy Free Admission.jpg
Talbot Spy online ad VFi 8.11.22.jpg
CBEC format 2 restore copy.jpg
Bay County Chorus April 2026 copy
1 2.jpeg
763ACTS 2020 DigitalAd BaC 300x500 final.jpg
Qlarant Spy ad 8 13 2025.jpg
2.png
Piazza Market April Vietti wine.jpg
Reeder contemporary Nov 2024 rev3 copy 2.jpg
unnamed
MSCF 300x500 2.jpg
FOT TheSpy
Trippe Oct 2026
0.png
Waterfowl Festival 2026
FAS NOSE SPY 300x500.jpg
unnamed
Avalon May 2023 copy.jpg
0.jpeg
massoni spy spring 2026
Spy Donor Thank You Ad
Morgan Stanley 1 copy
eswa ad talbot spy FINAL
Oysterfest Talbot Spy
MSO March 2026
YMCA Membership generic copy.jpg
Private Duty Care 300 x 500 Jan 2024 copy
TalbotSpy Ad 2023.jpg
massoni spy spring 2026