Op-Ed: Will This National Crisis Change the Gun Debate?


It’s too early to suggest that the El Paso and Dayton mass shootings will change the debate on guns or anything else, but one can hope.  On Monday, President Trump surprised many by condemning white supremacy. Various leaders, led by politicians but also athletes, entertainers, and businessmen, are speaking out.  The media is devoting entire programs to the issue of gun violence and the need for action. I’m encouraged. 

Dozens of pundits have commented that it takes a crisis to bring a community together.  The implication is that without a crisis, a community may be unable to form the type of consensus necessary to act. Skillful politicians know when a crisis has occurred and how to exploit it. Memorably, Rahm Emanuel, President Obama’s chief of staff, commented that, “You never let a serious crisis go to waste.  And what I mean by that it’s an opportunity to do things you think you could not do before.” Emanuel is right. Obama used the Great Recession to enact Obamacare. But only the next few weeks will tell whether the recent mass murders and the universal expectation that more will follow is enough of a crisis to build a national consensus to do something about gun violence. Hopefully it is.

For the time being, hundreds of thousands of people are demanding that something be done to end the epidemic of mass shootings. The ideas are familiar to many of us:  Expanded background checks, banning certain weapons, taking guns away from the documented mentally ill, registering guns, and things like requiring gun owners to maintain liability insurance to pay for the harm their gun might do. It can, of course, be questioned whether any or all these actions would prevent the next mass shooting, but it would be a start.  Whether the political will exists for those in the community who fear gun legislation to change their views is another question. Historically, calls for action after a shooting are loud but short-lived. After the shock of seeing pictures of murdered victims, especially children, things seem to go back to normal.   

Will this time be different?  Hopefully it will, but it won’t happen automatically. Legislators need to hear from enough constituents to become convinced that their jobs are in jeopardy if they “vote wrong.”  Legislators themselves need to demonstrate political courage by addressing those who are skeptical about new gun laws. Trusted legislators telling hunters and other gun owners that banning assault weapons and making it harder to buy a gun is not a forerunner to seizure of all guns will help a consensus to emerge. It can be done.

The drafting of legislation that gives us the best chance of reducing gun violence won’t be written if Democrats focus too much on blaming President Trump and racists for the most recent tragedies.   Progress requires civil discourse. Can Republicans and Democrats set aside the name calling and focus on find the common ground? It’s out there. It may not be everyone’s first choice for a solution, but it also may be our best shot at getting something done.  

J.E. Dean of Oxford is a retired attorney and public affairs consultant. He is a former counsel to the House Committee on Education and Labor.  For more than 30 years, he advised clients on federal education and social service policy. He is the former chairman of the National College Access Network (NCAN), a group promoting success in higher education among underrepresented groups, and KnowledgeWorks Foundation, a national leader in strategic foresight and education innovation. 


Letters to Editor

  1. Susan D. Gilbert says

    I suspect no one was more surprised than Trump was that he condemned white supremacy. His famous (already) “teleprompter speech” looked to be a total surprise to the reader, too.

    Nice try, Donnie.

  2. John P Aiken says

    Mr. Dean
    Your article on the latest mass shootings is not only fair and thoughtful but direct and to the point . How do we get the appropriate officials in government to take action now .. as you well know,we are all tired of the platitudes……… Our thoughts and prayers go out to the families ……….. from all of our elected officials and anyone running for office in the coming months . The whole nation has had enough . Are we resigned ,as a country ,to wait for the next killing spree only to repeat shock and condolences to families ?
    I think not .
    John P Aiken

    Easton MD

    • Mr. Aiken: Thank you for your comment. No easy answers to finding a way to get Congress to act. None of us should give up. It’s encouraging that the reaction, not just the outrage but, more importantly, the direct calls for specific bills to be acted on, is continuing. I’m hoping also for Governor Hogan to join the discussion and show some leadership on this issue.

  3. Richard Skinner says

    Dear Mr Dean – I think the answer to your question, “Will this national crisis change the gun debate?,” is “No.” We seem to have had, not a debate so much, as a shouting match. This, I think, is due in large part to the fact that that for many Americans the acquisition and possession of guns is not a question or a debatable matter. Rather, gun ownership is an absolute right. And unlike free speech or other
    rights, there are no shades or degrees to be parsed or analyzed.

Write a Letter to the Editor on this Article

We encourage readers to offer their point of view on this article by submitting the following form. Editing is sometimes necessary and is done at the discretion of the editorial staff.
We're glad you're enjoying The Talbot Spy.

Sign up for the the free email blast to see what's new in the Spy. It's delivered right to your inbox at 3PM sharp.

Sign up here.