“We have to save our democracy” has been the Democratic rallying battle cry for the past few years. In Maryland saving “our democracy” apparently means gerrymandering the last surviving safe Republican district out of existence.
Gov. Moore and the Legislature have drafted a new district map which would effectively eliminate the 1st Congressional District from being competitive for the Republican Party. The 1st Congressional District encompasses the Eastern Shore and is currently represented by Andy Harris (R). The Democratically controlled Maryland legislature has a history of gerrymandering Republican leaning districts out of existence. They have done such a banner job that the gerrymandered 3rd Congressional district earned the dubious distinction of being crowned as “the most gerrymandered district in the US” by The New Republic and The Washington Post. Congratulations Maryland. At long last, we are first at something!
As part of the “saving democracy” effort, the Democratic Left has conducted an onslaught on our institutions, traditions, and values, corrupting and reversing the very principles they claim to stand for; they have taken universal notions that once fell under the umbrella of “democracy” and cynically distorted their meaning to champion and promote a majoritarian/authoritarian superstate. Our founding fathers were not unaware of this very danger. They termed it the “tyranny of the majority”. In Maryland, this “tyranny of the majority” seeks to eradicate the sole surviving Republican-leaning district and deprive over one million registered Republicans in this state, including the totality of the Eastern Shore, from any effective Congressional representation.
In Federalist 10, the author of the Bill of Rights, James Madison addresses the issue of factionalism. Madison recognized the emergence of factions as inevitable for factions are natural to men whose very nature inclines them to create associations among men with like-minded interests. These various social, political and economic “factions” are today represented under the mega-umbrella of the two political parties. The question for Madison was how to manage the effects of factionalism to avoid the “tyranny of the majority” while balancing faction and cohesion. His answer anticipated the political impulse for gerrymandering: to avoid the “tyranny of the majority,” representative districts must be large and diverse in order to dilute the concentration of any single interest group, which could effectively suppress the varying number of minority interests. Larger districts, according to Madison, involve the inclusion of a greater number of parties and interests, which hamper the formation of factious majorities. Gerrymandering is exactly what Madison prescribed AGAINST: an impulse to create a district for the sole purpose of a single-faction political domination.
The Democratic Party has turned the entire state of Maryland into a gerrymandered entity; Madison’s worst fears have been realized. The new gerrymandered proposal for the 1st District, spanning the Eastern Shore, offered by the Democratic super-majority in the legislature, is designed for a single purpose: to eliminate the last Republican Congressional seat in the State of Maryland. The proposal is, in Madisonian terms, a de facto manifestation of the “tyranny of the majority”.
Gerrymandering has a long history in Maryland. It has resulted in oddly shaped districts drawn to concentrate and consolidate the power of the Democratic Party.
Many areas of Maryland with substantial Republican majorities have been targeted by gerrymandering (see Maryland 3 and Maryland 6), resulting in the dilution of the Republican voting power and representation. One infamous example already mentioned is the gerrymandering of the 3rd Congressional District: the district has undergone significant creative redrawing, including after the year 2000 and 2010 censuses, leading to its designation as the nation’s most gerrymandered district.
After the Democrats gerrymandered the 3rd Congressional District in 2011, they proceeded to gerrymander the 6th Congressional District, delivering both to the Democratic column. This effort by the Democrats was the subject of a high-profile test case before the Supreme Court, Benisek v. Lamone. The Court ruled that such partisan gerrymandering is a political question requiring a political resolution and not suitable for federal court adjudication.
On November 4th, Governor Wes Moore launched the Governor’s Redistricting Advisory Commission to consider redrawing the state’s maps in favor of Democrats once again.
The newly proposed congressional map favors Democrats in all eight of the state’s Congressional districts. The legislation has passed the House, and it has been sent to the Senate for its consideration, where the prospects for passage are, at the moment, uncertain. Sen. Bill Ferguson (D), the Senate Majority Leader, has expressed concern with the plan to effectively eliminate Maryland’s sole Republican seat in Congress, the 1st District, represented by Congressman Andy Harris.
This action on the part of Gov. Moore is a raw power grab, possibly advanced in pursuit of his own political ambition. If successful, it would certainly gerrymander him onto the 2028 national political map. The implementation of the proposed map for the 1st Congressional district would effectively deprive over one million registered Maryland voters of any representation at the Federal level. We now know the meaning of “OUR democracy”.
Tatiana Croissette is the former chair of the Kent County Republican Party











I was heartbroken to hear that Mike Hiner passed away last week. He was an incredible individual, and I was grateful to have the opportunity to work with him for over 20 years.